Show contents
The EU-US Privacy Shield was a legal mechanism for certain transfers of personal data from the European Union to certified companies in the United States between 2016 and 2020. On 16 July 2020, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) invalidated the underlying adequacy decision in its Schrems II judgment (C-311/18).
The Privacy Shield can therefore no longer be used for new or continuing data transfers. Since 10 July 2023, organisations may instead rely on the EU-US Data Privacy Framework (EU-US DPF) where the US recipient is actively certified for the relevant type of data.
Key facts
- The former EU-US Privacy Shield has been invalid since 16 July 2020.
- A historical Privacy Shield certification does not provide a lawful transfer mechanism today.
- The EU-US Data Privacy Framework is a legally distinct successor based on the European Commission’s 2023 adequacy decision.
- The decision applies only to organisations on the official Data Privacy Framework List and only within the scope of their certification.
- If the recipient is not covered, organisations may need Standard Contractual Clauses or Binding Corporate Rules. A transfer impact assessment and supplementary safeguards may also be required.
- The General Court upheld the adequacy decision in September 2025. As at 18 September 2026, appeal C-703/25 P remains pending before the CJEU.
What was the EU-US Privacy Shield?
The Privacy Shield followed the Safe Harbour system, which the CJEU invalidated in 2015. US companies could commit to a set of privacy principles administered by the US Department of Commerce. In 2016, the European Commission recognised an adequate level of protection for transfers to listed companies.
The system was designed to facilitate transatlantic data flows and provide individuals with rights and complaint channels. It did not remove the need to comply with all other applicable GDPR requirements for the processing itself.
Why did the CJEU invalidate the Privacy Shield?
In Schrems II, the CJEU found in particular that access to transferred data by US intelligence services was not limited in a manner essentially equivalent to the proportionality requirements of EU law. Individuals in the EU also lacked an effective remedy equivalent to that required by Article 47 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights.
The invalidity took immediate effect. Controllers and processors could no longer rely on the Privacy Shield adequacy decision. The Court confirmed that Standard Contractual Clauses remained valid in principle, while requiring an assessment of whether their safeguards can actually be respected in the destination country.
What applies under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework?
On 10 July 2023, the European Commission adopted a new adequacy decision for the EU-US Data Privacy Framework. It covers transfers to US organisations included on the Data Privacy Framework List maintained by the US Department of Commerce.
The new framework is based in part on additional safeguards for US signals-intelligence activities and a multi-layer redress mechanism that includes the Data Protection Review Court. In its first periodic review in 2024, the European Commission concluded that the relevant elements had been implemented and that the framework was functioning. It also called for continued monitoring and regular review.
In September 2025, the General Court dismissed an action seeking annulment of the adequacy decision. That judgment has been appealed. The pending case C-703/25 P does not itself suspend the adequacy decision, but organisations should monitor further developments.
Read more about the EU-US Data Privacy Framework
How to assess data transfers to the United States
1. Identify the data flow and recipient
Determine which personal data reaches the United States, which legal entity receives it, why it is processed and whether additional subprocessors are involved. Remote access from the United States may also constitute an international transfer.
2. Verify active DPF certification
Check the specific recipient on the official Data Privacy Framework List. The legal name, covered subsidiaries, active status and scope must match the actual transfer. For employee information, verify in particular whether the certification covers HR Data.
Participating organisations must re-certify annually. The check should therefore be documented and repeated at appropriate intervals.
3. Meet all other GDPR requirements
The adequacy decision does not replace a lawful basis for processing or a required data processing agreement. Transparency, purpose limitation, data minimisation, security, retention and processor selection and monitoring continue to apply.
4. Use an alternative transfer mechanism where necessary
If the recipient is not effectively covered by the EU-US DPF, the transfer requires another mechanism under Chapter V GDPR. Common options include:
- EU Standard Contractual Clauses,
- approved Binding Corporate Rules, or
- a derogation under Article 49 GDPR in narrowly defined situations.
When relying on Standard Contractual Clauses, organisations generally need to assess whether the law and practice of the destination country affect the effectiveness of the safeguards. Depending on the result, supplementary technical, organisational or contractual measures may be necessary.
5. Monitor onward transfers and changes
Check whether the US recipient sends the data to further service providers or other third countries. Contracts, provider lists and certification status should form part of ongoing privacy and supplier management.
Can organisations still use the old Privacy Shield?
No. The former Privacy Shield and the current EU-US Data Privacy Framework are separate legal arrangements. References to Privacy Shield certification in contracts, privacy notices or records of processing should be reviewed and updated. What matters is whether a valid transfer mechanism exists today.
Primary sources and current proceedings
- CJEU judgment in Schrems II, C-311/18
- Adequacy Decision (EU) 2023/1795 on the EU-US DPF
- European Commission’s first periodic review of the EU-US DPF
- General Court judgment in Case T-553/23
- Pending appeal C-703/25 P
- Official Data Privacy Framework List
Status: 18 September 2026. This article provides general information and does not replace an assessment of a specific transfer.